How to respond to begging and children asking for money or pens with kindness and dignity
I want to handle this thoughtfully not coldly and not naively When children or people ask me for money sweets or pens what is the right response I have read that giving to begging children can do harm encourage them out of school and so on but I do not want to be heartless How do locals and seasoned travellers handle it what actually helps versus what feels good but harms and how do I say no with warmth and respect This matters to me to get right Please share honest thoughtful guidance
7 Answers from travellers
Cultural guide and someone who cares about this so let me answer honestly The hard truth about giving to begging children most development and child welfare guidance says do NOT give money sweets or pens directly to begging children however kind it feels it can encourage families to keep children begging rather than in school it can make begging more lucrative than education and the sweets harm their teeth with no dental care the good feeling of giving can sustain a harmful pattern this is genuinely well established not coldness What actually helps instead if you want to help give to a REPUTABLE local charity school or organisation that supports children and families systemically (education meals healthcare) that is where your generosity does lasting good not the street handout support local people through FAIR economic exchange buy from them eat at their stall pay fairly tip generously for service hire the guide the tuktuk the cook this dignifies and sustains rather than creating dependency How to say no with warmth and dignity this is the key you asked a smile a friendly greeting in the local language eye contact and a warm but clear no treat the person as a person not a nuisance for children engage them as children (a chat a wave a smile) rather than a transaction the warmth costs nothing and honours their dignity even when you do not give what feels good versus what helps the handout feels good and can harm the charity donation and the fair exchange feel less immediate but actually help carry the discomfort of saying no kindly in service of the better outcome The approach do not give to begging children directly give instead to a reputable local organisation support people through fair paid exchange and say no with genuine warmth and respect that is how you do right by the people you meet
The buy from them and pay fairly rather than hand out point is the practical heart of it I started buying fruit and tea from the people who would have asked and it felt like real exchange with dignity on both sides
Local seconding all of this give through a known charity and support people by paying fairly for what they do the genuine warmth in how you decline is what people remember and it costs nothing
Carrying pens to give out is one of those feels good but harms things a teacher told me the children skip school to beg for them give school supplies to a school not a child on the street the destination matters
The warm clear no with a smile and a greeting genuinely works the cold ignore feels awful and the guilty handout helps no one treating the person as a person while still declining is the balance
Do not give directly give to a reputable organisation support people through fair paid exchange and say no with warmth this is exactly the thoughtful framing I was reaching for the dignity in the warm no matters as much as the decision thank you
To add the same applies to the photo for money requests and the orphanage visit trade pay for genuine service and skill not for poverty and avoid the orphanage tourism that the volunteering ethics threads warn against channel generosity through accountable local structures
Fair TukTuk Prices
Help travelers avoid overcharging!
Be the first to report a priceYou must be logged in to post an answer.
Log In to Answer